Protecting whistle-blowers is vital to fighting healthcare fraud
Protecting whistle-blowers is vital to fighting healthcare fraud
Every rand lost to fraud, waste, and abuse in healthcare is a rand that cannot fund medicines, improve benefits, or care for a patient who needs it.
But some of the most important information needed to protect those resources does not come from an algorithm, an audit, or a claims system. It comes from people prepared to speak up when they see something wrong.
Whistle-blowers can be the first to see the patterns that data later confirms. Yet asking people to expose wrongdoing without ensuring they will be heard, supported, and protected leaves a critical weakness in our fight against fraud, waste, and abuse.
At the Board of Healthcare Funders’ 25th Annual Conference, Head of the Special Investigating Unit (SIU) and Chairperson of the Health Sector Anti-Corruption Forum (HSACF), Leonard Lekgetho, indicated that up to 15% of healthcare claims may be tainted by FWA, amounting to some R30 billion lost annually.
His clearest message was that no institution can tackle this alone. The HSACF reflects this approach, bringing together civil society, law enforcement, regulators, government and the private sector. But collaboration is not enough.
Tackling FWA must also connect three things often addressed separately: intelligence, accountability and trust. We need stronger data and analytics to identify suspicious patterns, collaboration so information does not remain trapped in institutional silos, and whistleblower systems that make speaking up genuinely safe.
While technology can connect information at a scale once impossible, it cannot replace people. That is why stronger whistle-blower protection must form part of any credible FWA strategy. This theme was carried through at the conference in a presentation from Advocate Janine Mosetlhi, managing director of DaraConsulting.
Healthcare governance depends fundamentally on trust: members' trust in trustees, regulators' trust in schemes, and society's trust in institutions entrusted with scarce resources. Sometimes that trust rests on one person's willingness to speak when something is wrong.
Few cases illustrate this more powerfully than that of Babita Deokaran. An official in the Gauteng Department of Health, Deokaran halted R850 million in suspicious payments linked to Tembisa Hospital in August 2021 after uncovering a network draining public healthcare funds, and called for a forensic investigation.
On August 11, she warned the department's CFO that those implicated might realise they were "onto something" and that their lives could be at risk. Twelve days later, she was murdered.
Her story shows why whistle-blower protection cannot be reduced to a procedural compliance requirement. Protection must be more than words on paper. Disclosures must lead to credible action, and organisations must immediately act when risks to those who speak up emerge.
South Africa has a legal framework intended to protect those who report unlawful conduct, while the Medical Schemes Act places obligations on trustees to protect members' interests and manage risk.
However, an organisation can have a policy and a hotline yet still harbour a culture in which people are afraid to speak. Even where retaliation does not take such an extreme form as the Deokaran case, those who raise concerns can face exclusion, career stagnation, and isolation.
An effective whistle-blower framework therefore needs: strong governance, independent reporting channels, investigation integrity, protection and support, and a culture that encourages people to speak. Boards should monitor retaliation risk, reporting channels should allow anonymity, and leadership should visibly demonstrate that disclosures will be taken seriously.
A strong whistle-blower system cannot sit alongside a FWA strategy as a separate compliance function. It must be integrated into it. Asking employees to report wrongdoing without protecting them simply transfers institutional risk onto the individual.
There is another danger: collecting information without acting on it. Better analytics generate more alerts, while greater collaboration creates more connections between cases, but confidence depends on what happens next.
The HSACF's approach demonstrates the importance of timely investigations, secure reporting channels and referring allegations to those best placed to act. Trust is built not by having controls, but by demonstrating that they work.
This is what an integrated response to FWA should look like. Collaboration connects information across the system. Accountability ensures credible information results in action. And trust ensures that people who hold vital information are willing to come forward.
South Africa cannot afford a system in which one organisation sees part of the problem, another holds the data, a third has the authority to investigate, and the person who could connect the dots is too afraid to speak. The solution lies in building bridges between the government, the private sector, and civil society.
For the Board of Healthcare Funders and its members, this is not about protecting medical scheme balance sheets. It is about protecting the healthcare resources entrusted to us and getting better at safeguarding the money already in the system so it is spent on healthcare.
Babita Deokaran understood what was at stake. Her courage should compel us to build a healthcare system in which exposing wrongdoing does not demand extraordinary courage from an individual. A system in which data, institutions, and investigators are connected, disclosures lead to action, and those who speak up know the system will protect them as they seek to protect it.
Every rand preserved strengthens sustainability. Every disclosure acted upon strengthens accountability. Every whistle-blower protected strengthens trust. Fighting fraud, waste, and abuse is ultimately about building an integrated healthcare system capable of detecting wrongdoing earlier, acting on it faster, and protecting the people courageous enough to expose it.
